Thought I'd share with the group since this is the first time I've ordered one of these.
CJ was great to work with and made sure I was getting what I wanted. I did the design and e-mailed him the file and in about 10 days I had it in hand.
It's really quite nice and the price was good. $18 for the plate, with the $30 setup fee. It's 1/16" thick dark brown matte plastic, somewhat flexible, and it reminds me of a Fender Brown Amp faceplate.
Overall I'm pretty impressed.
Take a look: